Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Ole-Fashion Pies

Whether you are in the mood for a piece of pie or planning an event and need several pies, A Slice of Pie can accommodate your needs. Pies are sold in whole and half sizes. Or for a variety, try a "half-n-half" or sampler platter.

Slices are sold whole (1/5 pie) or half (1/8 pie).

Fruit & Berry Pies

 

Pecan, Tollhouse and Brownie

Whole Pie
Half Pie

  • Apple (American & Dutch)
  • Blackberry Crumb
  • Cherry Double Crust
  • Cherry Raspberry
  • Peach
  • Strawberry Rhubarb

$21.45
$13.00

Whole Pie
Half Pie

  • Pecan
  • Tollhouse
  • Fudge Brownie
    w/ ice cream (Plain, Nut, Mint, Snickers, or Reese's)

$23.95
$14.50

 

Cream Pies

 

Specialty Pies

Whole Pie
Half Pie

  • Boston
  • Chocolate (with Whipped Cream)
  • Coconut (with meringue or whipped cream)
  • Tahitian (with Whipped Cream)

$23.95
$14.50

Whole Pie
Half Pie

  • Custard
  • French Silk
  • Peanut Butter Lust
  • Sugar Free Custard (Splenda ®)

$21.45
$13.00

 

Frozen Pies

 

No Sugar Added Mini-Pies

Whole Pie
Half Pie

  • Key Lime
  • Mudslide
  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl

$21.45
$13.00

Whole Pie
Half Pie

(Large pies also available)

  • Apple
  • Blackberry
  • Cherry
  • Peach
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Bumbleberry

$8.95
$4.95

 

Sampler Platter

       

Whole Platter (14 Half-slices)

Small Platter (8 Half-slices)

$59.95

$33.95

 

     
 

Sides for Added Deliciousness

Large Whipped Cream (16 oz.)
Small Whipped Cream
Ice Cream (full)
Extra Cinnamon Sauce

$2.00
50 ¢
$1.85
50 ¢

   
 

Pie Crusts

 

Raw (2 pack)
Baked (each)

$4.25
$2.75

 

Gift certificates are available. Please order ahead for holidays and special events.

Download our Printable Menu and place your order today.

Call 573-364-6203

Cash or Check only. No credit or debit cards please.